Skip to Main Content
Blog

Consignment, Estate Sales, or Online Auctions: Which Secondhand Marketplace Is Right for You?

Estate liquidation services are becoming a big business. Understanding how to maximize the proceeds of a home’s contents is incredibly valuable, and navigating the various avenues can feel overwhelming. Assessing the values of items through current market data is crucial to properly pricing them and maximizing resale value. From secondhand marketplaces offering a wide range of items like accessories and shoes to other resale platforms, the options are vast. We’ve been in this industry for over a decade, so stick with us as we walk you through your options.

Benefits of Using a Secondhand Marketplace

Using a secondhand marketplace can be a treasure trove of unique finds and a smart way to engage in sustainable shopping. Here are some compelling benefits:

  • Sustainability: By choosing secondhand, you reduce waste and support a circular economy. It’s a small step that makes a big difference for our planet.

  • Affordability: Secondhand marketplaces often offer items at a fraction of the cost of new ones. Whether you’re hunting for a vintage dress or a gently used sofa, you can find great deals that fit your budget.

  • Uniqueness: One of the joys of secondhand shopping is discovering one-of-a-kind items that reflect your style. From retro furniture to rare collectibles, the possibilities are endless.

  • Community: Many secondhand marketplaces foster a sense of community. Buyers and sellers often connect over shared interests, creating a network of like-minded individuals.

  • Convenience: Online marketplaces make it easy to browse and purchase items from the comfort of your home. With just a few clicks, you can find exactly what you’re looking for without the hassle of traditional shopping.

Types of Secondhand Marketplaces

Secondhand marketplaces have become increasingly popular in recent years, offering a wide range of options for buyers and sellers alike. Here are some of the most common types:

  1. Estate Sales: Estate sales are a fantastic way to find a diverse array of items, often due to downsizing, relocation, or the passing of a loved one. These sales typically feature everything from fine jewelry and antiques to household goods and collectibles. Estate sales are a treasure trove for those looking to find unique items at fair market value.

  2. Consignment Galleries: If you have high-end, gently used items to sell, consignment galleries are an excellent option. These galleries specialize in art, fine jewelry, and other luxury items, offering both in-person shopping and online sales. Clients benefit from the gallery’s expertise in pricing and marketing, ensuring their items reach the right audience.

  3. Online Marketplaces: Platforms like eBay and Craigslist have revolutionized the way we buy and sell secondhand items. From the comfort of your home, you can browse a vast range of categories, including electronics, clothing, furniture, and collectibles. These online marketplaces make it easy to connect with buyers and sellers worldwide.

  4. Thrift Stores: Thrift stores, such as Goodwill and Salvation Army, offer a wide range of donated secondhand items. Shopping at these stores not only helps you find great deals but also supports charitable causes. You can find everything from clothing and household goods to furniture and appliances, all at budget-friendly prices.

  5. Auction Houses: For those looking to buy or sell high-end, rare, or unique items, auction houses are the place to go. These sales, which can be held in-person or online, often feature art, antiques, and collectibles. Auction houses attract serious buyers, making them ideal for selling valuable items to the highest bidder.

Consignment Stores and Upcoming Sales

When someone chooses to sell something on consignment, they are making a third party the point of sale. Consigning an item means asking a professional to sell that item on your behalf, either in their retail establishment or at an event they’re running. In return for their services, the third-party seller receives a percentage of the selling price. Promoting consignments through various marketing channels, such as emails and postcards, is crucial to inform potential buyers about these items.

Consignment storefronts have a limited amount of space and relatively low foot traffic. Inventory turnover rates can be slow. Because of this, consignment shop owners tend to be very picky about the goods they accept and will typically lean towards higher-end items. Generally speaking, if a consigned item does not sell within the first few weeks, it will be subject to large price reductions until it is sold or retrieved by the original owner.

Consignment sale events are typically held over two to four days and feature a larger buyers' network. Items are dropped off by consignors and are displayed along with all of the other consigned items. The likelihood of selling an item in this environment is higher, as these events tend to attract a large audience. Consignment sales often offer great deals on various items. Advertising and engaging customers with detailed information about upcoming sales is essential to maximize attendance and sales. While specifics vary from event to event, it is not uncommon for consignors to pay a required flat fee, as well as up to a 40% commission charge.

Consignment stores and events can work to liquidate a small number of select belongings. Again, consignment shops are looking for attractive, big-ticket items. Consignment events, on the other hand, can work well for lower-end items, especially if the event revolves around an associated theme. Yard sales are another popular method for selling secondhand items.

Online Auctions for Fine Jewelry

Online auctions have been around for quite some time, with eBay continuing to reign as the most widely known. Depending on the company, an online auction representative may first vet potential sale items. Others leave the evaluation of what will perform best on the shoulders of the sellers. Users can create accounts to participate in online auctions and receive notifications.

Once photos and descriptions are created, the action begins. Auctions always take place over a specified amount of time. Once the time is up, the highest bidder wins the item. Some auction companies will allow a starting price or a reserve to be placed on an item. In that case, the item will only sell once a certain benchmark is achieved. Other online auction companies start every item at $1. This process can be exciting for buyers but incredibly stressful for sellers, especially when the auction company’s commission is taken into account. Some online auction platforms offer free shipping within certain regions.

Like estate sales, online auctions can include a wide variety of inventory, ranging from crystal stemware to gardening tools. Auctions can be great for buyers as there is always the potential to find a hidden gem at a low price. As a seller, auctions are risky. Sure, there’s the potential for a bidding war if just the right people happen to be paying attention to a desirable item, but, more often than not, items sell for less than fair market value.

Auctions also require time and energy. If you plan to list items online yourself, be prepared to put in some serious work, especially if you want to maximize your profits. Even if you’re interested in taking a chance and handing your pieces off to the pros, the process isn’t overnight. Prepping, researching, shooting, and describing items well is laborious. Add in a week-long sale, and you’re looking at quite a while before you get your cut of the sale.

If you’re looking to sell an extremely desirable item or two and are willing to roll the dice and wait to achieve highly uncertain results, an online auction may be a good option for you. If you have a large, somewhat random assortment of belongings, it’s probably not your best bet. At the end of the day, you will most likely be left with varying success in terms of selling those top-tier items and little to no success in moving the more common items.

Traditional Estate Sales

Thousands of estate sales happen every weekend across the country, but many are still confused as to what they are and how they work. Historically speaking, “estate” refers to the total of a person’s possessions upon his or her death. These days, the meaning is far less somber. Here at Blue Moon Estate Sales, the vast majority of our clients are simply downsizing. With billions of dollars of perfectly good, unwanted items crowding people’s homes, a quick, efficient way to cut the clutter is much sought after.

Many estate sales are scheduled in July, providing an opportunity to find great items during the summer. These sales often include a diverse range of items such as art, Fine Jewelry, Timepieces, Sterling Silver, and Coins.

Estate sale companies play a crucial role in organizing these events, ensuring everything runs smoothly. Rather than putting loads of time, energy, and luck into online auctions or letting items sit for weeks hoping that they’ll sell in a consignment shop, our clients look to us. The need for an estate sale tends to come about with a great change in a person’s life. That can be stressful. We take the headache out of the equation, place items into the hands of happy shoppers, and put a check in the mail, lickety-split.

We’ve set new standards in the estate sale industry. With our comprehensive training, proprietary technology, and top-notch marketing, we can clear an average household over a weekend. Not only that, but we also pride ourselves on our exceptional ethics. When it comes to working in people’s homes surrounded by their possessions, morality is crucial.

If you are looking to quickly and easily unload a large number of items, all at fair market value, a traditional estate sale may be the perfect option for you. Do some research to find a trusted company in your area. Ask to speak to former clients, and read reviews. Above all, if a company attempts to make a deal based on a handshake alone, do not let them into your home. At Blue Moon, we use clear contracts that protect everyone involved.

Helping others is what drives us. Our business model is proven, and our happy clients and customers speak volumes about the service we provide. If you’re in need, reach out today.

How to Choose the Right Marketplace

With so many secondhand marketplaces available, finding the right one can feel overwhelming. Here are some tips to help you make an informed choice:

  • Research: Start by looking for marketplaces that specialize in the items you’re interested in, whether it’s estate sales, consignment galleries, or online platforms for fine jewelry and antiques. This ensures you’ll find a curated selection that matches your needs.

  • Reputation: Check the marketplace reputation by reading reviews and ratings from other buyers and sellers. A well-regarded platform is more likely to provide a positive experience.

  • Fees: Understand the fees associated with buying and selling on the marketplace. This includes commission rates and payment processing fees, which can vary significantly between platforms.

  • Ease of Use: Choose a marketplace with a user-friendly interface. A well-designed website makes it easier to list items, browse sales, and complete transactions smoothly.

  • Customer Support: Look for marketplaces with responsive customer support. Whether you have a question about a sale or need help with a consignment, good customer service can make all the difference.

Tips for Buying and Selling on Secondhand Marketplaces

Maximize your secondhand marketplace experience with these tips:

Buyers:

  • Research the seller and the item before making a purchase. Read reviews and check the seller’s ratings to ensure a trustworthy transaction.

  • Ask questions about the item to clarify any details before buying.

  • If possible, visit the seller’s physical location, such as a consignment gallery, to inspect the item in person.

Sellers:

  • Take high-quality photos and write detailed descriptions of your items. Clear, attractive listings are more likely to catch a buyer’s eye.

  • Set competitive prices by researching similar items for sale. Pricing your items right can help them sell faster.

  • Respond promptly to inquiries and messages from potential buyers. Good communication builds trust and can lead to quicker sales.

  • Consider offering discounts or promotions to attract more buyers. Special deals can make your listings stand out.

General Tips:

  • Keep track of your purchases and sales using a log or spreadsheet. Staying organized helps you manage your transactions efficiently.

  • Use social media platforms like Facebook to promote your items and connect with other buyers and sellers. A strong online presence can boost your sales.

  • Consider partnering with a business or consignment gallery to help manage your sales and marketing efforts. Professional assistance can streamline the process and increase your success.

By following these tips, you can navigate secondhand marketplaces with confidence, whether you’re buying or selling. Happy shopping!

Getting Started with Secondhand Marketplaces

Diving into the world of secondhand marketplaces is easier than ever, thanks to the variety of options available. Here are some steps to help you get started:

  1. Research Local Options: Begin by exploring local secondhand marketplaces, such as estate sales, consignment galleries, and thrift stores. Check their websites, social media pages, and online reviews to get a sense of the items they offer and their sales processes.

  2. Create an Account: If you’re interested in online buying or selling, set up an account on platforms like eBay, Craigslist, or Facebook Marketplace. Follow all safety guidelines and best practices to ensure smooth transactions.

  3. Log In and Browse: Once your account is set up, log in and start browsing available items. Use filters and search terms to narrow down your options, and read descriptions and reviews carefully before making a purchase.

  4. Visit In-Person: For those who prefer in-person shopping, visit local secondhand marketplaces to see items firsthand. Don’t hesitate to ask questions or negotiate prices, and always inspect items carefully before buying.

  5. Get Involved: Engage with the secondhand marketplace community by attending estate sales, joining online forums or social media groups, or volunteering at local thrift stores. This involvement can help you stay updated on the latest trends and upcoming sales, and connect with like-minded individuals.

By following these steps, you can start exploring secondhand marketplaces and uncovering great deals on gently used items. Whether you’re a buyer or seller, these marketplaces offer a wealth of opportunities to find unique treasures, make some extra cash, and contribute to a more sustainable world. Happy shopping!